Demystifying the Debate: Mutual Funds vs ETFs Pros and Cons

Mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are two popular options for investing in the stock market. As an investor, choosing between mutual funds and ETFs can feel overwhelming given the variety of options available in both categories. This article aims to help you understand the key differences between mutual funds and ETFs to determine which may be a better fit for your investment goals and risk tolerance. We'll explore the pros and cons of both and how each can play a role in a diversified portfolio. This article is published by Dealnew to help investors make informed decisions about mutual funds versus ETFs.

What are Mutual Funds?

A mutual fund is a professionally managed investment product that allows investors to pool their money together to purchase a variety of stocks, bonds, and other securities. Mutual funds are run by fund managers who make all the investment decisions, buying and selling assets to achieve the fund's stated objective. The two main types of mutual funds are open-ended funds, which issue new shares on a continuous basis, and closed-end funds, which have a fixed number of shares that trade on a stock exchange.

Some key things to know about mutual funds:

  • Actively managed funds have portfolio managers who trade securities actively trying to beat the overall market return. Index funds passively track a market index like the S&P 500 without active trading.

  • Most mutual funds have a minimum investment requirement, often $1,000 or $3,000, while some funds have even higher minimums of $10,000 or more.

  • Mutual fund prices are determined once daily after the market closes based on the net asset value (NAV) of the underlying holdings. You'll receive the closing price for the day your purchase or sale order is placed.

  • Mutual fund expenses, like management fees, affect your overall return. Expense ratios generally range between 0.1-2% annually but can be higher for some actively managed funds.

What are ETFs?

An exchange-traded fund (ETF) is a basket of securities (like stocks or bonds) that trades on a stock exchange just like a stock. ETFs have different investment objectives just like mutual funds - some track stock indices, commodities, or bonds. The main difference is that ETF trading happens throughout the day on an exchange, while mutual funds are priced only once per day after hours.

Some key things to know about ETFs:

  • Most ETFs track market indices very closely, though some are actively managed. Index ETFs aim to mirror the returns of indexes like the S&P 500 very cost-effectively.

  • ETF share prices fluctuate continuously during trading hours based on buyer and seller activity. You'll receive the market price at the time of your trade.

  • ETFs generally have lower expense ratios than mutual funds, often below 0.5% annually to track indexes passively. Some specialized ETFs charge more for active management.

  • You’ll need a brokerage account to purchase ETFs since they trade like stocks. Most mutual funds don’t require a broker depending on purchase method.

  • ETF minimum investments are usually the price of a single share - around $25-100. Many mutual funds have higher minimums of $1,000 or more as noted above.

Mutual Fund Pros

  • Professional management - Mutual funds are actively managed by professionals researching companies and sectors. This provides a level of expertise individual investors may lack.

  • Diversification - By investing in many stocks, bonds, and assets classes through one mutual fund, you achieve instant diversification that may be hard to attain otherwise. This can reduce risk.

  • Low cost for some funds - While not all, index funds tracking major indexes like the S&P 500 are among the lowest-cost investment options available. Their expense ratios are typically well under 0.5%.

  • Automatic investments - Many mutual funds allow you to setup automatic monthly or quarterly investments seamlessly from your bank account. This facilitates dollar cost averaging.

  • Tax efficiency - Some funds are tax-managed to minimize capital gains distributions, providing potential tax advantages over regular trading.

Mutual Fund Cons

  • Fees - Actively managed funds must pay managers and incur trading costs, regularly charging 0.5-2% or more annually in expenses that degrade long-term returns.

  • Less control - You have no say in the fund’s holdings and must rely on the manager’s investment strategy and performance which are not guaranteed.

  • Liquidity - Some mutual funds impose short-term redemption fees if shares are sold within a period like 90 days to deter trading. This limits liquidity.

  • Minimums - As mentioned, higher mutual fund minimums of $1,000 or more are common and may not suit small investors or regular contributions.

ETF Pros

  • Low cost - Most ETFs tracking broad market indexes like the S&P 500 charge well below 0.1% in fees, providing the most cost-effective market exposure available.

  • Tax efficient - Besides bonds, most ETFs do not generate large capital gain distributions as no holdings are sold for cash to meet daily redemptions.

  • Transparency - You can see all an ETF’s holdings daily as they mirror the tracked index. There’s no ambiguity about what you own.

  • Flexibility - ETFs trade continuously just like stocks, so you can buy or sell them whenever the market is open. No waiting until the end of the day to get a price.

  • Diversification advantages - Some niche or international ETFs allow instant exposure to entire markets or factors that may be otherwise difficult to access.

ETF Cons

  • Brokerage fees - Each ETF trade through a broker like Fidelity, Schwab or E*Trade costs $5-10 which eat into returns for small, frequent traders.

  • Market exposure - Unlike mutual funds that price once daily after hours, your ETF holdings rise and fall along with the market during trading sessions. This exposes you to more volatility risk if rebalancing regularly.

  • Leverage risk - Leveraged and inverse ETFs that aim to double or inverse daily market moves through derivatives can experience tracking errors over time if held long term.

  • Competing products - With over 2,000 ETFs launched, separating the standouts from redundant products requires extensive research as some fade over time.

Mutual Funds vs. ETFs: Which is Best?

For most long-term investors, either a low-cost mutual fund or ETF can make a great core holding providing broad market exposure at minimal cost. The best approach is to consider your unique investment needs, preferences, and the specific offerings available.

  • If you want fully managed exposure to global markets with automatic investing, a low-cost index mutual fund is probably your best bet.

  • For taxable accounts, ETFs have a slight edge due to possibly lower tax impact over mutual funds with capital gains distributions.

  • If you trade frequently, ETFs will likely be cheaper overall due to lower ongoing costs eating away returns instead of periodic broker fees.

  • Small portfolios below mutual fund minimums are usually better served by low-minimum ETFs.

  • Both have a role to play - while an ETF tracks the total market, allocating a portion of your portfolio to well-researched actively managed mutual funds could boost returns.

In summary, for most small portfolios especially in taxable accounts best utilized for long-term buy-and-hold exposures, low-cost index ETFs and mutual funds should be your first consideration due to their blended advantages. This article aimed to compare mutual funds versus ETFs to help you make an informed choice for your unique situation. We hope it provides insight into these two popular investment vehicle options. This article was published by Dealnew to help explain the pros and cons of mutual funds and ETFs.

In closing, while mutual funds and ETFs both provide easy diversified exposure to markets, understanding the differences between the two is key to determining which vehicle, or blend of both, fits your investing needs and preferences. Whether you decide to invest primarily in mutual funds, ETFs, or a mix of the two, keeping costs low remains integral to long-term success. Comparing funds on objective criteria like fees, holdings, and performance can help you identify which offerings are best positioned to meet your goals. With diligent research, both mutual funds and ETFs offer potent core or satellite holding options for building robust, low-maintenance portfolios. I hope this article published by Dealnew has helped shed some light on mutual funds versus ETFs.

Read more: 

When to Get Help: The Top Signs You Need a Financial Advisor

Reduce Daily Living Expenses: Simple Tips to Spend Less Without Compromise